Growing Tomatoes: Choosing Varieties, Planting and Harvesting

by David Schulze

Waiting for the first ripe tomato is part of the pleasure of gardening. A good homegrown tomato brings flavor, color and plenty of possibilities to the kitchen, whether you want a thick sandwich slice, a handful of cherries or a basket for sauce.

My favorite is the Sungold cherry tomato. I could happily snack on those little golden fruits all day. David loves Brandywine beefsteaks, especially sliced onto a burger.

Growing tomatoes is also a lesson in paying attention. What works in one garden may need adjusting in another, and the same planting can behave differently from season to season. Choose varieties that suit your climate, start sturdy seedlings and give the plants consistent care and room to grow.

Choose Tomatoes for the Way You Eat

  • Beefsteak and slicing tomatoes: Substantial slices for sandwiches, burgers and fresh plates. Mature fruit size varies by variety.
  • Cherry, grape, pear and currant types: Small-fruited choices for snacking, salads and quick cooking, with different shapes, textures and flavors.
  • Paste, plum and Roma types: Often meatier and less watery, making them useful for sauces, roasting and drying. Not every paste tomato is the same variety.
  • Colorful varieties: Tomatoes can ripen red, pink, yellow, orange, green, dark or striped. Learn your variety's mature appearance rather than waiting for every fruit to turn red.

Determinate or Indeterminate?

One of the questions we hear at the Farm Store is what “determinate” means. The first time someone asked me, I did not know either. Being Mrs. David's Garden Seeds®, I felt I ought to learn!

Determinate tomatoes generally reach a more limited size and produce a relatively concentrated harvest. They can be useful for processing, but do not all stop at the same height or ripen every fruit within one week. Many benefit from cages or other support.

Indeterminate tomatoes continue extending their vines and can flower and fruit over a longer period while conditions permit. They usually need substantial support and adequate space. Heat, disease and other stresses can interrupt production before frost.

Compact types can be convenient for containers, but growth habit alone does not determine suitability. Check mature size, container volume, drainage, support and watering needs. Some indeterminate types can also grow in appropriately managed containers.

Open-Pollinated, Heirloom and Hybrid Choices

Open-pollinated varieties can reproduce recognizable traits when pollination and seed saving are appropriately managed. Heirlooms are traditionally maintained varieties, but not every open-pollinated variety is an heirloom.

F1 hybrids are deliberately bred crosses selected for particular characteristics. Some offer excellent flavor, useful disease resistance or reliable growth habits. Neither the heirloom nor hybrid label guarantees flavor or performance, and resistance is not immunity. Check the actual variety's listed resistance.

Seed saved from an F1 hybrid can grow, but the next generation may vary rather than consistently reproducing the original hybrid. Hybrid breeding is not the same as genetic engineering, and a purple tomato is not automatically genetically engineered. Read our guide to seed types.

Use Our Favorites as a Starting Point

Our favorites have included Sungold, Supersweet 100, Juliet, Tycoon, Celebrity, Brandywine, Arkansas Traveler, Homestead, Rose and Cherokee types. These reflect tomatoes we have enjoyed growing, not a promise that each will excel in every garden.

Compare maturity, mature size, growth habit and documented disease resistance with local recommendations. Consider a manageable mix of small-fruited and larger-fruited varieties rather than expecting one plant to meet every goal.

Plan Around Your Local Growing Season

Tomatoes are frost-sensitive. Use local planting guidance to decide when to start seed and set out transplants. A hardiness-zone number alone does not describe your last frost date, summer heat or best planting window.

Starting seed indoors roughly six to eight weeks before your intended transplant date is common. Adjust to the variety, growing setup and local recommendations. Starting too early can leave you managing tall, crowded or rootbound plants before the garden is ready.

Texas Timing: Spring and Fall Crops

Texas does not have one tomato-planting date. South Texas, Central Texas, the High Plains and other regions differ in frost timing, wind and summer conditions. Getting plants established before intense summer heat is often important in South Texas.

Starting seed in January can fit some spring plans, but it is not a statewide requirement. Work backward from your county's recommended transplanting window. Set plants outside when soil and nighttime conditions suit tomatoes; one warm afternoon does not mean cold nights are over.

For fall tomatoes, many Texas regions need established transplants in summer, well before autumn feels cool. Do not assume you can wait until September to start seed. Check Texas A&M AgriLife Extension's fall vegetable guide and your county's recommendations.

Start Strong Tomato Seedlings

  1. Use clean containers with drainage. Fill with suitable seed-starting mix and moisten evenly.
  2. Follow the packet for depth. About 1/4 inch is common. Cover gently without compacting the mix heavily.
  3. Provide suitable warmth. A mix temperature around 75–85°F generally encourages germination. A temperature-controlled heat mat can help in a cool growing area; avoid overheating.
  4. Give seedlings strong light. Provide a bright growing area or suitable grow lights following the manufacturer's guidance, plus gentle air circulation. Weak, stretched growth often indicates insufficient light.
  5. Water without waterlogging. Bottom watering can help, but drain excess water rather than leaving ordinary pots standing continuously in deep water.
  6. Make room as plants develop. Thin or move seedlings into larger containers when roots and foliage need space. Reduce or remove bottom heat once it is no longer needed.

Many seeds emerge in roughly five to ten days under favorable conditions, but timing varies. Poor emergence can involve seed condition, temperature, moisture, depth or growing mix rather than one universal cause.

Review our seed germination guide, soil-testing guide and soil-temperature guide for background.

Harden Off Before Transplanting

Gradually introduce indoor-grown plants to outdoor sun, wind and temperature changes over about a week or two. Begin in a sheltered location and increase exposure as plants adjust. Protect them from cold and severe weather, and monitor moisture because small pots can dry quickly outside.

Choose sturdy, healthy transplants with a developed root system. Height alone is not a reliable measure of readiness: a shorter, compact plant can be better than a tall, weak one. See our hardening-off guide.

Plant in a Sunny, Well-Drained Bed

Give tomatoes about six to eight hours of direct sun when possible and soil that drains well. Use soil-test guidance for amendments. Containers need drainage holes and enough root volume for the variety.

Space plants according to mature size and support system, leaving room for inspection, watering and picking. Two or three feet is not a universal answer for every variety and training method. Crowded foliage can stay wet longer after rain.

Non-grafted tomatoes can form roots along buried stems. Remove leaves that would be below soil and plant more deeply, or lay the lower stem gently in a shallow trench with the growing tip above ground. Do not bury leaves, sharply bend the stem or place the root ball in cold, poorly drained ground. Water transplants in thoroughly and keep concentrated fertilizer away from roots.

Grafted plants are different: Keep the graft union above the soil and follow the supplier's instructions. Allowing the upper stem to root can defeat the purpose of the rootstock.

Install Supports Early and Prune Thoughtfully

Install cages, stakes or trellises before plants become large to reduce root disturbance. Match support strength to mature vines and fruit weight. Use soft ties that support stems without constricting them, checking ties as plants grow.

Suckers grow where leaves meet the main stem. They are not automatically useless growth and can develop flowers and fruit. Pruning depends on the growth habit, support method and climate. Avoid heavy pruning of determinate plants; removing productive shoots can reduce their concentrated crop.

Indeterminate plants can be trained to suit the structure, but removing every side shoot is not mandatory. David generally avoids heavy pruning in our Texas conditions because leaves help shade fruit. Stripping healthy foliage can expose tomatoes to sunscald.

Remove damaged or diseased growth as appropriate and leaves touching soil. Use clean tools, especially when disease is a concern, and avoid working through wet foliage.

Water Consistently and Feed Thoughtfully

Check root-zone moisture and water deeply enough to reach roots. Adjust to rainfall, soil type, plant size and temperature instead of following a fixed calendar. Containers may need more frequent checks than beds. Allow air back into the soil rather than keeping it continuously saturated.

Drip irrigation or a soaker hose can help keep foliage dry. Mulch after soil has warmed to conserve moisture and reduce soil splash, leaving space around stems. Avoid severe drying followed by heavy watering, which can contribute to cracking and other problems.

Use a soil test and fertilizer directions rather than guessing. Excess nitrogen can favor leafy growth over fruit, and more phosphorus is not automatically better. Measure applications and keep concentrated products away from roots and stems. Do not assume well water or excavated sand has a beneficial nutrient balance without current testing.

Manage Texas Heat

Prolonged hot days and warm nights can reduce fruit set even when plants look healthy. Neither determinate nor indeterminate growth guarantees production through extreme heat, and no single temperature is a universal cutoff for every variety.

Extra fertilizer does not fix heat-related poor fruit set. Keep root-zone moisture appropriate, mulch and consider well-ventilated shade cloth during intense conditions while preserving enough light. Shade cloth is not a wildlife barrier.

Some Texas gardeners use separate spring and fall plantings rather than expecting one crop to perform equally well all summer. Greenhouses and tunnels still need ventilation and temperature management; an enclosure alone does not prevent pests or disease.

If plants wilt while soil is already moist, investigate roots, drainage and disease symptoms before adding another soaking.

Recognize Leaf Differences and Common Disorders

Some tomatoes have deeply divided, toothed foliage; others have broader, smoother-edged potato leaves. Leaf form can be a normal variety trait. Compare with the variety description rather than using leaf shape alone to identify every tomato.

A dark, sunken patch on the blossom end may be blossom-end rot, which involves calcium supply to developing fruit. Inconsistent moisture, root problems and other conditions can contribute. It is not automatic proof that soil needs more calcium.

Cracking, leaf spots and wilting have different causes. Check growing conditions and seek your local Extension office's help with unfamiliar or recurring symptoms.

Identify Pests Before Spraying

Inspect leaf undersides, stems, growing tips and fruit for insects, eggs, caterpillar droppings and damage. Not everything on a tomato plant is harmful. Encourage natural enemies and handpick confirmed pests when practical. Hornworms carrying visible cocoons of beneficial parasitoid wasps can be left for those natural enemies to develop.

Do not choose spinosad simply because a bug is tiny, use a general fungicide for every leaf spot or routinely alternate sprays without a diagnosed problem. Insecticidal soap is a contact treatment for certain pests, not a lasting preventative shield.

If treatment is needed, use a product labeled for tomatoes and the identified problem. Follow application directions, temperature restrictions, pollinator precautions and harvest intervals. Organic products can still harm plants and helpful organisms when misused.

Harvest and Store for Flavor and Quality

Learn your variety's ripe color and feel. Tomatoes that reach the breaker stage, when the first mature color appears, can be harvested and finish ripening indoors. This can reduce losses from cracking, weather, sunscald or animals. Immature green fruit is not the same as fruit that has begun ripening and may not develop good quality.

Flavor depends on variety, growing conditions, maturity, handling and storage, not solely on staying attached until fully colored. See Penn State Extension's tomato harvest guide.

Let sound, uncut fruit finish ripening at a moderate room temperature out of direct sunlight. Check regularly and use ripe fruit promptly. Refrigerate cut tomatoes promptly. Fully ripe tomatoes can be refrigerated to slow spoilage, though chilling can affect texture and flavor.

Important Tomato Canning Safety

Do not assume vine-ripened tomatoes can be safely canned without added acid. Color, flavor and ripeness do not replace a tested preservation process. Lower acidity means a higher pH, not a lower one.

Use a current tested recipe from the National Center for Home Food Preservation, USDA or Extension. Follow every instruction for preparation, acidification, jar size, processing method and altitude. Standard directions for whole, crushed or juiced tomatoes require acidification, including when a pressure-processing option is provided.

Do not use a home pH reading as permission to skip required steps or invent a process. Start with the National Center for Home Food Preservation's tomato acidification directions and the tested recipe for your product.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why are my plants large but not producing?

Possible causes include excess nitrogen, insufficient sunlight, temperature-related poor fruit set or plants not yet at their fruiting stage. Check conditions before adding fertilizer.

Should I water every day?

Not on a fixed schedule. Check moisture and weather. A container in summer heat may need daily attention, while an in-ground plant in cool weather may need much less frequent watering.

Do I need to remove every sucker?

No. Prune for the variety, support system, space and climate. Preserve enough foliage to support the plant and shade fruit.

Can I prevent every pest problem?

No, but regular inspection, suitable growing conditions and early targeted action can keep many problems manageable. Seek local Extension help for unfamiliar symptoms.

Keep Learning from Each Planting

Record varieties, sowing and transplant dates, first harvests and recurring problems. Compare performance over more than one season. Your own observations are more useful than a long list of untested tricks.

For bed layout and practical neighboring crops, read our Companion Planting Guide.

Find Your Next Favorite Tomato

Explore Tomato Seeds from David's Garden Seeds® and choose varieties for your garden and kitchen.

Grow something beautiful. Grow something delicious. Grow with David's Garden Seeds®.


Leave a comment

Please note, comments must be approved before they are published